Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kim Douglas's avatar

Love this! I'm reminded to use with my own beta-readers ... I'd give direction on the feedback. Not to limit people, but to focus them in a helpful way for a first draft. The Best rules I've encountered were in an Advanced NonFiction Seminar taught by a Washington Post rockstar new journalist (yes, friends with Gay and Nan Talese), author and prof.

Keep comments to:

- something you like,

- something you don't like,

- places that confuse or lose the reader in some way.

Wildly helpful for the writer when people stick to it.

Expand full comment
Marisa's avatar

"That said, I have no idea if this will work or not. Whatever happens, [...] we’ll hopefully both learn something." This is a great attitude! Good luck and that sounds exciting and fun :)

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts